Payton Creek Catfish House in Conway

Payton Creek Catfish House in Conway
4 / 5
50 reviews

393 Highway 64 E Ste A, Conway, AR 72032-9416, Conway

Overview

Cuisine
  • Seafood

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do they still have the quail

Yes i had it yesterday...just make sure you get yourself some fast cuase ppl are like hawks swoop down once is put out on the buffet area.

Was this formaly known as Payton Creek Catfish Company ?

Yes

Do they have crab legs?

Yes but I believe u pay extra! They are not included on buffet!

Do they still serve frog legs? How about quail?

Quail on Friday night and frog legs on Saturday night. Peel and eat them shrimp both nights

How much is the buffet per person?

It is worth every penny it costs!!

Do you all still do the all you can eat fish? If so , how much ?

It's $16.99 which includes your drink as of 22/22/2019. Senior discounts are available.

When do they Quail?

IIRC Friday is Frog Legs, Saturday is Quail

Does hidden valley catfish serve alcohol?

Would be nice to wash down all thay oil!!! I dont recall anyone drinking booze just sweet tea and soda.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Payton Creek Catfish House
KC
Kim Cameron
google
11.06.2024
4/5

Food was great...pretty spicy but good, a little crowded but the staff was on top of everyone's needs.

Payton Creek Catfish House
AH
Angela Hutchins
google
10.27.2018
5/5

We came from Texas for a family reunion and we always eat Catfish the night before. Great customer service. Ambulance was called on m ugh wife and the helped out and checked on us often till they arrived. Can't wait till next year when we go back

Payton Creek Catfish House
GE
Georgia Etheridge
google
10.22.2018
1/5

There is a good variety of food. The catfish was very good but just about everything else was loaded with pepper and hot spices. We do not care for spicey food. It would be great if they let people put their own seasoning instead of making it so spicey that we couldn't eat it.

Payton Creek Catfish House
ST
Seanisti Turnage
google
10.18.2018
5/5

We love this place! Everything is great and even have good quality. Not to many buffets where you’ll get good service and great food! If you see a bad review don’t believe the hype! There’s absolutely nothing wrong with this “hidden valley buffet” and I mean NOTHING! Those who are making 1 star reviews are obviously very judgmental and senseless! BEST CATFISH HANDS DOWN!!!

Payton Creek Catfish House
NP
Nena Padron
google
10.12.2018
4/5

Good buffet. Catfish good. Peel n eat shrimp good. Love those crab shells with stuffing. However, they have issues with dirty silverware and dishes. So go, but look closely before using plates, bowls and silverware. Price for me $16...reasonably priced for seafood and catfish. This type of food is NOT cheap.

Payton Creek Catfish House
TU
Tod Underhill
google
10.07.2018
3/5

Lots of fried foods. All tasted good. Very flavorful boiled shrimp. Buffet was crowded and difficult to navigate sure to its tight location near front register. Dining room was very crowded and difficult to walk through due to close table arrangements. Wait staff was friendly and helpful.

Payton Creek Catfish House
RA
Rocky Alan Shelton
google
09.15.2018
5/5

Very good food! Down-home atmosphere!

Payton Creek Catfish House
SR
Sheila Rieathbaum
google
09.02.2018
4/5

Was good variety of food and delicious but fried foods were cooked way to fast and hard on the outside and inside was almost not cooked enough

Payton Creek Catfish House
DS
Danny Shoffner
google
08.05.2018
5/5

Best catfish in Arkansas. endless peel em and eat em shrimp. gumbo made from scratch.abd great dessert's.

Payton Creek Catfish House
PG
Pam Goff
google
07.09.2018
5/5

This was our first time to go here and it was wonderful! The fish was hot and fried crispy. There was a variety of Fish, Cajun fish, chicken, shrimp, deviled crab and quail. The sides were wonderful with a large variety. In addition there was a wonderful salad bar and desert bar. I would highly recommend Hidden Valley and will definitely be back!

Payton Creek Catfish House
BU
Bob Upton
google
06.04.2018
5/5

Friendly, Country style catfish house. If you love fried foods, you'll be in heaven. Besides catfish, on my visit they had fried okra, mushrooms, pickles & jalapeno peppers. They also had traditional country sides of greens, green beans, corn on the cob & other favorites. Not to mention the peel-em eat-em shrimp. It is a hidden gem just outside of Conway.

Payton Creek Catfish House
RF
Rob Fisk
google
05.05.2018
5/5

A little pricey but you get what you pay for

Payton Creek Catfish House
BL
Beverly Lloyd
google
04.26.2018
5/5

Best catfish place around conway. The cajun fish was seasoned perfectly. Hush puppies, fish, shrimp and crab wonderful buffet. Loved the family atmosphere and friendly staff. Large selection on the buffet.

Payton Creek Catfish House
CW
Chris Williams
google
04.13.2018
4/5

This place has kinda went downhill since the previous owners sold it. Still good and still holds most of the same quality as before but a little diminished. Frog legs are still good if not better than before. Green tomato relish is the best i have ever had. Prices went up so i dont visit near as often as i did. I have been going to this place for over 20 years and never had 1 bad experience.

Payton Creek Catfish House
CF
Carlinn Ford
google
03.22.2018
4/5

Food is great. Wait staff is cordial. The location is marked well, even though it is "hidden" by a couple of hills. Prices are in line with other restaurants in the area (near Conway). I'm part of a group who eats there almost every month and I seldom hear a complaint.

Payton Creek Catfish House
TA
Tina Arter
google
03.15.2018
4/5

Good seafood buffet. Fish,shrimp, stuffed crab...

Payton Creek Catfish House
JT
Jerry Tanner
google
01.26.2018
5/5

Great food and friendly service.

Payton Creek Catfish House
EM
Earlene McGee
google
11.27.2017
2/5

I don't like spicy food. Cabbage and green beans use to be good now they have something hot in them. Fish is still good.

Payton Creek Catfish House
GB
Garland Brown
google
11.24.2017
5/5

We spend way to much time here. The food is so good and a reasonable price.

Payton Creek Catfish House
JW
Joannie White
google
11.22.2017
5/5

Good food, great service.

Payton Creek Catfish House
RS
Red Sonja
google
10.15.2017
3/5

Great selection, However a lot of the food was way over seasoned and was so hot I nor my child could eat it.

Payton Creek Catfish House
TG
Tim Grooms
google
10.12.2017
5/5

Great tasting food, great selection.

Payton Creek Catfish House
PN
Patrick Nowlin
google
09.25.2017
5/5

Great food! Great price!

Payton Creek Catfish House
MG
Marc Griffin
google
09.20.2017
3/5

The food is not that good, although there is plenty of variety. Most catfish places in the area are better than this one. That said, I wouldn't pass on it if I'm craving a seafood buffet and don't have time to drive to another one. They're very friendly and the service is great.

Payton Creek Catfish House
YS
Y Smith
google
09.18.2017
4/5

Like the atmosphere. It's got Cajun spice. But maybe just a tad too much. Everything is almost too hot to enjoy without drowning the heat with your drink.

Payton Creek Catfish House
RM
Robert Mead
google
08.10.2017
5/5

Great shrimp and catfish

Payton Creek Catfish House
GS
Geanie Sarringar
google
08.02.2017
4/5

Food was good no salt on fish the white beans needed to cook another hour okra was not done enough to suit me also the air conditioning was out. Rather eat at Searcy or quitman

Payton Creek Catfish House
AR
Arthur Reid
google
06.20.2017
5/5

Great Food and Customer Service in this place. They take pride in keeping Fresh Hot Food on their bar!!! You will NOT be disappointed.

Payton Creek Catfish House
LM
Linda McCarther
google
06.03.2017
4/5

We enjoyed it very much and we always do. The people are so nice and friendly and the fish is good.

Payton Creek Catfish House
ba
brad adams
google
05.18.2017
5/5

Excellent food, including some of the best shrimp, I have had on a buffet but you should bring your own fan, it is really hot inside the restaurant in the summer. My guess is existing A/C can't keep up. Could definitely use a mini split.

Payton Creek Catfish House
PD
Pam DeLong Rowe
google
05.07.2017
3/5

We have eaten here many times and the food has always been great. They had huge frog legs and great, large fillets. I guess they have changed management, again. We went a week ago and we were terribly disappointed. The frog legs were very small, the catfish fillets appeared to have been cut down the middle, they were thin strips and cook so long it was like eating crust. They have added mac and cheese and broccoli rice casserole, which are both very good. But, at 7:30 they were out of mac and cheese and when I asked if there would be more, I was rudely told no! We had to wait on fillets and frog legs when we first got there and then went back twice and had to wait. I really hate this has gone down like it has, it has always been one of our favorite places to eat, every other week. I'm not sure we will any more.

Payton Creek Catfish House
SM
Sharon Minton
google
05.02.2017
5/5

I would highly recommend this buffet. I took a Party of 10 including 3 kids---great meal and included food kids loved. Catfish, Shrimp,Quail, Chicken fingers crisp tender hot and not greasy.Vegetables including french fries crisp as well Great dessert ---Friendly staff who were attentive--kept the drinks filled and table cleared. We went at a busy time and the staff also kept the fresh food coming out of kitchen. WE will be back!!!

Payton Creek Catfish House
JM
Jesse Macom-Teague
google
04.22.2017
4/5

Great food! Just plain old school fish buffet with all the trimmings. Plenty to eat. The staff is friendly as can be. The only downside is the price. Almost thirty bucks for my son and I. The place was clean and everyone seemed to be family too. Pretty good overall. I will go back. But it's a bit too pricey for a regular trip. Special occasions or a splurge treat for sure.

Payton Creek Catfish House
Arkie407
google
03.15.2017
5/5

Ribs were great; smokey sweet glaze & tender. Canjun fried catfish was very tasty w/o hot spices. Great attentive staff. Reasonably priced for the selection of food & all you can eat buffet...

Payton Creek Catfish House
MH
Melissa Huguet
google
03.13.2017
3/5

The food is ok, unique variety was nice! Not exactly "fancy", but all you can eat at a fair price. Eating areas were tight, the buffet areas were close together and next to a kitchen with no door. Not everything was clearly labeled, and the staff didn't really say much. At least they were not rude.

Payton Creek Catfish House
CC
Cameron Copeland
google
03.01.2017
5/5

Loves this little hideaway. Great buffet and down home feel.

Payton Creek Catfish House
LT
Lynn Thomas
google
02.10.2017
4/5

I love this place. My only complaint is there are very few sides that are not spicy hot. I feel they should have more choices for kids and chickens like me. The potatoe salad is spicy, the green beans are spicy, the fried mushrooms are spicy, the greens are spicy, the cooked cabbage is spicy! Those are all things I would eat if they were not spicy. Could you do a pole of customers to see if they would like more non-spicy choices?* * *Since I wrote this, they have added some new choices that are kid friendly and adult friendly (Mac n Cheese). I'm not sure about all the changes, but I still love this place. Their specials by night are: Fridays are Quail nites and Saturdays are Frog Leg nites! As for the spicy foods, you could always put Tabasco sauce out for those who want heat instead of IN the items.

Payton Creek Catfish House
cc
carolyn candybow@att.net
google
02.10.2017
1/5

Not worth the drive for the money. Food cold that should have hot. Dirty silverware. Parking lot was full.

Payton Creek Catfish House
HG
Heather Gaston
google
01.12.2017
2/5

Small selection for the price. Friendly service gets busy quickly. Overall ok place to go.

Payton Creek Catfish House
NG
Nicole Gable
google
11.26.2016
1/5

Took my mother here for mother's day and it was very disappointing. With catfish in the name one would think they would have an abundance of catfish, but that was not the case by any means. The buffet was a joke. When they eventually replenished the empty dishes by the time I got back up to the line they were empty again. Definitely won't be back.

Payton Creek Catfish House
RS
Raymond Selken
google
11.03.2016
5/5

Great buffet, lots of fresh food! Love it

Payton Creek Catfish House
JB
Joshua Bingham
google
11.01.2016
5/5

Always love going here. Prices are high, BUT the food is always amazing.

Payton Creek Catfish House
BB
Brian Bailey
google
09.10.2016
1/5

Hopefully I just went on a bad night. So I will simply leave it at that ☹️

Payton Creek Catfish House
JS
Joyce Stubbs
google
09.10.2016
5/5

Very delicious food hot managers and waitress everyone so nice

Payton Creek Catfish House
BS
Brenda Smith
google
08.20.2016
5/5

Service is Awsome. Food is the best. I love going to eat there. Worth the drive.

Payton Creek Catfish House
HB
Heather Bluemoon
google
08.20.2016
2/5

Maybe it was a bad night since we had heard great things about this restaurant, but the fish was soggy and "fishy". The batter on the chicken and the hush puppies were way too spiced in my opinion. I doubt I will be back.

Payton Creek Catfish House
SS
Shawna Satchell
google
07.21.2016
5/5

I absolutely love this place!!! Its beautiful on the outside. And the food was food for my soul. I enjoyed it.

Payton Creek Catfish House
JG
Jan Glasspoole
google
04.21.2016
3/5

Veggies and cobblers COLD. Catfish ,shrimp was good

Payton Creek Catfish House
bh
bev hamelback
google
04.09.2016
1/5

Too expensive for the little offering.

Payton Creek Catfish House
EB
Evette Browning
google
03.07.2016
4/5

Fresh hot real catfish fish. Some veggies were salty.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 15014507335

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!